Strict FDI rules take a toll on Amazon’s largest seller Cloudtail


November 29, 2018

Written By Sagar Malviya & Writankar Mukherjee, ET Bureau

MUMBAI | KOLKATA: Amazon India’s largest seller Cloudtail crossed the Rs 5,000 crore sales mark in the year to March but growth tapered off significantly, indicating its fading role as the company seeks to comply with foreign direct investment (FDI) rules on marketplaces.

The government said last year that it will not permit a single vendor to account for more than 25% of sales on an online marketplace that has overseas investment.

Cloudtail, a joint venture between Amazon Asia and Infosys founder Narayan Murthy’s personal investment vehicle Catamaran, posted over a 24% jump in revenue to Rs 5,688.7 crore in FY17, according to its annual return.

That’s against a 300% surge to Rs 4,586.9 crore in the previous year when it accounted for over a third of the sales on Amazon’s shopping platform in India.

“With the restriction, it was very clear that growth had to be moderated. But Amazon would still prefer to channel their goods through a seller where they can control margins and inventory,” said Devangshu Datta, CEO, Third Eyesight, a consultancy firm. Amazon India declined to comment. Cloudtail didn’t respond to an email.

Cloudtail’s numbers pale in comparison with Flipkart’s biggest seller WS Retail, which posted sales of Rs 13,921 crore for the year ended March 2016. It hasn’t filed a financial performance report for the last fiscal yet but Flipkart has also been reducing its dependence on the seller, in which its founders used to own a stake.

After the government’s guideline, which ecommerce companies had to comply with by March 31, 2017, Cloudtail almost stopped selling mobile phones a year ago but continued with Amazon private labels in India. Smartphones constitute the largest category of India’s ecommerce sales and formed a big part of Cloudtail’s overall sales in previous years.

“With the smaller pace of growth by exiting smartphones, Cloudtail will surely comply with the FDI norms of one seller accounting for 25% of total transactions at Amazon last fiscal itself,” an executive said.

Another seller said Cloudtail’s gaze is on consumables such as FMCG, nutrition, apparel and televisions, which are the next focus areas for Amazon. Personal care, baby care and nutrition are also of interest. It currently sells Amazon exclusive television brands like TCL, Sanyo and BPL.

Source: economictimes

Alibaba’s Singles’ Day sales: Are the Indian and Chinese e-commerce sectors like apples and oranges?


November 15, 2018

The numbers were 27 percent higher compared to the sales last year with $24 billion of gross merchandise value (GMV)


Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba sold a record $30.8 billion worth of products on its 24-hour Singles’ Day sale.

The numbers were 27 percent higher as compared to the $24 billion of gross merchandise value (GMV) of sales last year.

Even though China is facing major geopolitical and economic challenges, the story on Chinese middle-class consumption on November 12 was different altogether.

Last month, India also had one of its biggest online shopping festivals, but reported a fraction of this number at $2.3 billion during five-day period.

What got Alibaba to achieve the $30.8 billion GMV target in 24 hours is the trust placed by the Chinese consumers, the consolidation of online and offline retail, the categories of products, the income and expense of the Chinese consumers and others, according to the analysts.

While we can say that both China and India have almost the same population size, it will not be appropriate to compare the size of online e-commerce market of China and India.

“China’s online e-commerce market was between $900 billion to 1 trillion in 2017 whereas India’s e-commerce market was around $18-20 billion. There is a significant difference in size of the market in both countries,” said Ankur Pahwa, Partner and National leader, E-commerce and Consumer Internet, EY.

Income and consumption power plays an important role for a consumer. “The economies of China played an important role in the spending habits of the Chinese. The GDP per person in China is around $9000 whereas in India, it is around $2000,” said Pahwa.

Devangshu Dutta, Chief Executive of Third Eyesight said, “I don’t think that Indian and China can be compared at par. There is a huge difference in their income and consumption profiles.”

But what lessons should other e-commerce platform learn from Alibaba?

Trust plays a very important role in an online e-commerce market. Alibaba, with its closed ecosystem, has developed trust with its consumers. Indian e-commerce still lags behind on this factor.

“Quality and trust played a very important role for Alibaba in China. Also, a large part of the Chinese economy is virtual. Whereas in India, a majority of buying is still from offline,” said an analyst.

Alibaba said that more than 40 percent of consumers made purchased from international brands

. “Indian e-commerce should give a mix of categories to its consumers. Proper curation of the inventory should be there in order to target Tier 2-3 cities. Another lesson one can learn from Alibaba is the dealings with the brands,” said analyst.

Alipay plays an important role for Alibaba. “Alibaba has integrated all ecosystems in its e-commerce business. From Alipay to its logistics. It has provided qualitative and seamless experience for its consumers,” said an analyst.

Online and Offline markets

Dutta added, “Alibaba has consolidated its hold on both the business and the consumer side in the Chinese ecosystem. India still has a fragmented consumer market, and online retail is only a couple of percentages of the total market, though the supply side is consolidated between the two foreign-owned businesses, Flipkart Group and Amazon. In India, I think both online and offline formats need to evolve together.”

Source: moneycontrol